One of the primary reasons I started learning how to sew my own clothes is because nowadays I prefer modest fashion. And being someone who has sensory issues, it can be a huge struggle to find ready-made clothes that suit all of my needs.
A problem came up a couple weeks ago when we went to the trampoline park for the first time ever and I realized I had only ONE shirt in my entire wardrobe which was appropriate for heavy physical activity! I ended up needing that shirt 3 times in the same week, it was our daughter’s spring break, and I only have time to do laundry once a week. (But for the record, it was a very fun week full of exciting activities!)
Since I’m on a No Buy this year and clothes are on the banned list, my only option was to learn to sew basic tees myself!!
My checklist for a perfect tee shirt:
- 100% plant based fibers. Cotton, rayon, etc. (A little tiny bit of spandex, like 1-3% or whatever, is fine. I can’t afford silk or linen, but I would try them! I’ve heard they’re hard to sew though.)
- NO WOOL! I am allergic! (Everyone gushes about merino, but ALL wool makes me itch like crazy. It’s a very mild allergy so I can still use my wool pressing mat for ironing, but wearing it directly on my body is a no-go.)
- 0% polyester. No blends. (It is way too insulating, makes me sweat like nothing else, and it gets stinky after the first wear every time.)
- Must feel soft, be lightweight and breathable.
- No scratchy tags, itchy seams, or anything uncomfortable whatsoever.
- Elbow length minimum, preferably 3/4 or full long sleeves. Long is the most versatile, as I can always roll them up.
- Crewneck, mock neck, or very high boatneck.
- Long enough to tuck into a skirt.
So obviously, that is a lot of criteria to meet! I had only one shirt in my entire wardrobe that met all these conditions, and I wanted to clone it. Not wanting to seamrip my favorite shirt apart, I began searching for a pattern I could use.
My first attempt, made with a free pattern by Life Sew Savory, was a complete flop. The pattern is fine, I would even recommend it for someone who likes this style! It just wasn’t what I needed. Her website is wonderful though, it’s bursting at the seams with all sorts of free patterns!
The neckline was WAY too low for my standards. I did make the shirt oversized on purpose, and that did contribute somewhat to the size of the neck hole, but even at the “correct” size it still would not have been a crew neck top.

Even though the fabric was 100% free from my local library’s fabric swap, I didn’t want to waste it. Especially not elusive cotton jersey! Stretch fabrics are a bit rare at the swap, our sewing community is primarily made up of quilters. I was quite blessed to find such perfect fabric for free, especially enough to make an entire shirt from! I’m even a fan of the bold crazy print!
Putting my favorite tee against it, I realized that making a whole new smaller shirt was totally possible, given I had made it two sizes larger than my actual size. It came in handy that I like a loose oversized fit!
However, searching for patterns left me feeling quite frustrated. None of the free ones were quite what I wanted, and I am not paying to print out a pattern, especially not for a basic tee. If I pay for a pattern it better be ready made, I HATE printing patterns, and I do not have a projector. If you know, you know!!
Then I had an idea that felt like a gray area for my No Buy… I might not be willing to seamrip my favorite shirt, but I would certainly be willing to chop up a secondhand shirt I don’t care about at all. I knew for absolute certain that this would be cheaper than the cheapest patterns I saw online.
I decided to try only one thrift store. My intention was to find a shirt that fit me perfectly, that I would never wear otherwise, and wouldn’t feel bad about disassembling. If I didn’t find something on the first try, that would serve as my sign that doing this would violate my No Buy. If that were the case I would continue looking for patterns or attempt to self-draft.
This turned out to be way easier than I expected. In under 5 minutes I found a poly cotton blend tee with a really silly graphic in a color I’m not particularly fond of wearing, that just so happened to be the most perfect fit I could possibly imagine. It was $2. That might have been my quickest successful thrift store trip to date!

Just like I promised myself, once I got home I had a date with my seam ripper and my television. It was actually quite therapeutic! I took my time taking apart both the new shirt and the shirt I had previously made.
I didn’t take very many process photos, which I regret now, but I didn’t go into this project expecting to make a blog post. Hopefully you can still get an idea of how I went about using the shirt as pattern pieces.
Below you can see how I folded the front bodices in half and pinned them together, and then cut the larger one to be the same size as the smaller one.

I repeated a similar process for all the pieces. However, I made sure to “mirror” the sleeves since they are slightly asymmetrical, there is a specific left sleeve and right sleeve. I just laid the two sleeve pieces wrong sides together and cut them from the same sleeve pattern piece. I’m not the best at explaining things without providing a visual demonstration, so I hope that made sense.
Once I was done with cutting out each piece, I traced my pieces onto wrapping paper to create a pattern I can use again and again! I will definitely be making several of these. I also plan to use it, shortened to about waist length, to create a dress bodice. Now that sounds like a blog post waiting to happen… Hopefully I will remember to take more pictures!
Assembly was more or less the same the second time around, and it turned out basically perfect.


I made the executive decision to leave the bottom hem and sleeve edges raw. This fabric does not easily fray or unravel. I find raw edges to be comfortable and less bulky.
There’s a pajama shirt I had to cut the cuffs off of, the serged seams were very itchy against my wrists, but now with raw edges I love it. That is what inspired me to leave the sleeves raw on purpose. And since I always tuck in my shirts, I hate the feeling of my skirt waistband against my skin, there was no reason to hem the bottom either.
In my opinion, this didn’t violate my No Buy. Because I used it as a sewing pattern, which are not off-limits this year, and I walked out of the store with only exactly what I went in for. I feel very satisfied and in line with my goals.
I don’t think it truly wasted a shirt, either. There is an unbelievable amount of clothes in the world, many of which go to landfill after only a few wears, or sometimes no wears at all. I save all of my scrap fabric and I either use it for other projects, stuffing, or donate it to my fabric swap. This donor shirt will be no exception. Perhaps if I donate it, someone will feel called to put it back together, or transform it into something entirely new! I feel happy that I gave a cheap garment with a short lifespan new life.
That’s all for now. Thanks for stopping by! See you next time.




















